NO BASE FOR IMPEACHMENT. If happen,
may aggravate nation Problems
Re-reading
my
CRITIQUE TO CHOSSUDOVSKY ART ON TRUMP- COMEY ISSUE
Hugo Adan May
14, 2017
Please focus on points 4 below & excuse statements’
duplicity.
Hugo Adan. May 20, 2017
These are extracts of my critique..to Chossudovsky
article:
1-
“The recommendation to fire Comey did not emanate from the
White House. It was an
initiative of US Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Deputy Attorney
General Rod Rosenstein,”
1-Have the Att Gral n the D-Att Gral from the
Judiciary System over ruled the President authority of the White House?. The FACT is: they didn’t dismiss Comey…Trump
did it.
MC made intentional dis-contextualization of Facts. So, there is wrong premise
for a flawed argt. -with wrong intention:
LIBERATING TRUMP from direct Resp on his dismissal
issue
Fact 1: Comey-fire was done by T, in his typical Gvt style, the day Wed 11 of
may 17, and via twit (the irresponsible way in which a President talk with the
Nation).
Sessions-Rosenstein suggestion are irrelevant on this issue. The fire
of Comey is Trump direct responsibility.
Fact 2: Saying that the cause of Comey’ fire is related to “the Clinton email investigation and the release of his
October 28, 2016 Second Letter to Congress 11 days before Election Day.”. .
is the excuse, not the direct cause of “Comey fired”.
I'm NOT defending Comey.. no way. I’m against of using this charade to cover
the main issue: the non-punishment of Clinton illegal and criminal hide of e-mails
and the RU gate full of phobia manipulated by Clinton-Obama with the
complicity of neocons. Aim: hit RU= start WW3.
The deep cause is Trump plans for WW3; more exactly, COMEY
was accused of investigating Trump
relations with RU.. On ISIS ans what else?. No
clear yet, but Trump was afraid of it. Some scholars argue that the issue was WW3
–its relation with domestic politics- seems to be the investigation by FBI
on Trump. IF so, it is not COMEY who caused that problem “RU-gate” The cause was
Trump misconception and mishandling of the relation with RU and China. Situation aggravated by the conflict in Asia (N-K)
and the chances of WW3 derived from it. This problem didn’t happen in 2016 but
in 2017 .. Comey dismissal did happens in 2017 nor 2016. That is that I called dis-contextualization of Facts.
2-
“Trump was manipulated into
accepting and endorsing the Attorney General’s initiative.”
Manipulation implies handling puppets to trick audiences.
In politics it is deceiving people by
turning of situations to take political advantage: affirming legitimacy, in this case.
Trump is the one doing so (though the effect of this act came back as a boomerang on his head), Comey was not taking political advantage. It was Trump who did it and Att Grals have been
used by Trump to hide his irresponsible and
dysfunctional way of handling Gvt. A trick can be effective on its expected
effects, but in politics this is a prove of big Gvt inefficiency. Trump is auto-destroying the trust in his
Gvt and trust in the “democratic system”
we supposed to defend. He is showing a
nasty-authoritarian style of Gvt based on fear, typical of nazy regime in which
THE FURER has to be obey not matter what. Mr Comey and the
Att Grals were here subsidiaries and
lesser evils of Trump manipulation, not its main actors.
3-
Who was behind the firing of COMEY, qui bono? Who benefit?.
Shossudovsky answer is: The GOP.
In MC argument this implies:
1. That Trump –is not direct actor- and not the main beneficiary, but the GOP. That is a flawed argt, false at
all. Trump is a GOP and while he belongs to this party, his acts make the party
accomplice of his faults. This will be so, until Trump is not expelled from
this party, or key members start abandoning the party. If that happens, Trump
may try to unite the party by fostering, declaring or starting WW3 by using nuke missiles on
N-Korea or any place. Is this what some in the Deep State are expecting? Could be..
2. Actor n main beneficiary could be the same person. So: the one who
nurder or order the murder is also its main beneficiary. In Comey’ fire case, we are
seeing the splitting of main actor from main beneficiary, that is a cheap way
of exonerating Trump’ fault and Comey' “misdeminors”.
4-
Motivation: The miss-uses
of context
A-
To say that the
firing of Comey “was motivated by US foreign policy and US-Russia relations”, is
true and false at the same time, depending on “prove”.. or irrefutable
evidences on either way. The context is a constant in
any analysis, it always exist, but its CONTENT depends
on players acting on it. To say that the Attorney General’s were the main actors
is to say that they override the authority of the President. That makes non-sense in the current
context, that is a total distortion of facts and reality.
Besides, the Foreign Policy
context it is in fact an EXTERNAL FACTOR helping to explain political actions,
but not necessarily the main motive or
cause of those acts. Internal factors must prevail in serious analysis. Acts
belong to actors and in the same context people can act different and even in
opposite ways.
B-
Some specialist argued the mental illness of Trump to explain
his acts and the source his evilness to others, including to the whole humanity
if WW3 happens. Paranoid Schizophrenia was argued as mental illness. If
prove, that would be enough to take him from power. But there is no way to
force him to take a professional test on this regard. He can argue that he was
tested by democratic election. To argue insanity on him is arguing insanity of
our democratic system. I don’t think we will go so far. Then, the only option we
have for his impeachment is to pile all his acts that account for professional negligence and breaches to US constitution. Then
we will have base for his impeachment. That
base does not exit now. Besides, his impeachment won’t
solve nothing. I may aggravate Nation problems.
C-
While those in the
top do the corresponding investigation on this issue, people
in the bottom should mobilized to streets to reject the nasty “regime change” operations used outside
to submit poor countries of US periphery, and now using inside to depose one billionaire
and keep the whole system of billionaire-oligarchies ready to replace the old
one and do worse things to our nation. We don’t want
imperial terrorism outside and we don’t want fascistic authoritarianism of the billionaires
inside.
What we want are consistent & workable plans to go beyond
the obsolete neoliberal economic model that is now collapsing and plans
for WORLD PEACE, justice and real democracy. The US can succeed if those plans
become reality; we have the tech and human capital to do it.
All that we have to do is abandoning the old myth of military
supremacism. That strategy doesn’t work anymore: our militarism drained
our economy, destroyed our productive capitalism, is responsible the huge and explosive
social internal inequality and is also
responsible for the barbaric destruction of human infrastructure of entire
state nations.
We need to realize that this un-ethical, inhumane military supremacism
arrived to its end since the nukes and tech-biological-chemical weapons can
destroy the whole world. We need to disassemble all of them and create a plan
for humane coexistence of today super-power nations. There is not space for
military supremacist anymore. We don’t need them We need to re-start the re-construction of
the damage created by neoliberal imperialism. We need a new world system, not
for the few, but for all people in our planet. We need
to avoid WW3 and forge a powerful PEACE global MOV.
----
----
POST SCRIPT:
On this issue I would recommend the reading of these articles:
Who killed Seth
Rich? The Russia hacking fiasco is a
regime change operation.
----
This is why Trump may
be broken and/or removed as President of the US
----
----
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario